If there’s one thing Anguilla knows how to do aside from boasting some of the most breathtaking beaches in the Caribbean, it’s serving up incredible food. This tiny island may be small in size, but it’s bursting at the seams with culinary gems, from hidden beachfront shacks serving up just-caught seafood to elegant restaurants where you’ll be treated like royalty.
Whether you’re staying at Fountain Anguilla or just exploring the island, prepare your taste buds for an adventure. Below, we will share with you the top Anguilla dining picks in specific order, based on visitors’ reviews and requests. Let’s take a delicious journey through these unforgettable dining spots, each offering its own unique take on paradise-on-a-plate. Plus, we’ll make it easy for you to plan your visit with distances from The Fountain Anguilla so you can hop in your car and follow your cravings. Buckle up, food lovers, this is the ultimate guide to eating your way through Anguilla!
Madeariman Restaurant – Shoal Bay
If you’re looking for casual, toes-in-the-sand dining with bold Caribbean flavors, this is your spot. Madeariman is all about unfussy, delicious food with an unbeatable beachfront view. Situated directly on the pristine Shoal Bay East, literally 2-minute drive away from The Fountain, Madeariman offers a delightful beachfront dining experience. The menu boasts a variety of seafood dishes, including fresh lobster and fish, as well as international favorites like pizzas and pastas. The relaxed atmosphere, combined with live music on select evenings, makes it a must-visit spot for both lunch and dinner. The seafood pasta is a must, and their grilled lobster? Absolute perfection.
20 Knots – Shoal Bay East
A 3-minute drive or a leisurely 10-minute walk away from The Fountain is 20 Knots, the chic-yet-relaxed beachfront restaurant at Zemi Beach House on Shoal Bay East. 20 Knots is the kind of place where time slows down, and every bite feels like a mini vacation. 20 Knots takes the bright, sun-drenched flavors of the Caribbean and weaves them seamlessly with Mediterranean influences, creating a menu that’s both comforting and exciting.
If you love light, zesty, and ultra-fresh seafood, this dish is a must. Imagine tender chunks of just-caught fish, marinated in citrus juices, kissed with a hint of heat from local peppers, and topped with fresh herbs. Every forkful is a burst of tropical sunshine.
As a seafood lover, the Lobster & Mango Salad is everything! Nothing says Anguilla indulgence like sweet, buttery lobster tossed with ripe, juicy mango, fresh greens, and a delicate citrus dressing. This salad is equal parts refreshing and luxurious.
For the foodies who prefer meat or veggies, 20 Knots has something for you too. And of course, you can’t forget dessert. The coconut panna cotta is light, creamy, and delicately sweet, while their chocolate lava cake is pure decadence—think warm, gooey chocolate oozing onto your plate, just waiting to be devoured.
Tropical Sunset – Shoal Bay
Tropical Sunset is a favorite for those who want simple, delicious food without the fuss. It’s the kind of place where you can linger over a cocktail and let the ocean waves set the rhythm of your evening.
We would recommend this spot for lunch! Their grilled snapper, conch fritters, and a killer rum punch are what you should order when you get here. This spot is the definition of no-frills, all-flavor island dining. The vibe is relaxed, the drinks are cold, and the view? Straight-up mesmerizing.
Just a few more minutes away are some noteworthy foodie spots.
The Pit Stop by Ben – Island Harbour, Anguilla
This roadside restaurant is approximately a 10-minute drive away from The Fountain. For those seeking an authentic local experience, The Pit Stop by Ben offers traditional Anguillian dishes in a cozy setting. Known for its hearty portions and friendly service, the menu features items like grilled crayfish, stewed goat, and a variety of seafood options. It’s an excellent spot to immerse oneself in the island’s culinary traditions.
Artisan – Island Harbour, Anguilla
Artisan is not just a restaurant, it’s an experience, a love letter to authentic Italian flavors and a haven for pizza lovers. But we’re not talking about just any pizza; we’re talking about wood-fired, Neapolitan-style masterpieces, the kind that have crispy, charred edges, a pillowy-soft center, and ingredients so fresh you’d swear they were flown in straight from Italy.
With its cozy, open-air setting, the ambiance here is effortlessly romantic and rustic, making it perfect for a relaxed dinner under the stars. Whether you’re a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, a lover of fine wines, or someone who simply appreciates the magic of good food made with heart, Artisan Anguilla is a must-visit. And with it being just a 10-minute drive from The Fountain Anguilla, there’s really no excuse not to indulge in a night of wood-fired bliss.
Hibernia Restaurant & Art Gallery – Island Harbour, Anguilla
Hibernia offers a unique dining experience by combining exquisite cuisine with an art gallery showcasing pieces from around the world. The menu is an eclectic mix of Asian and European influences, featuring dishes like Thai-style fish and duck breast with tamarind sauce. The serene garden setting and curated art collection enhance the overall dining experience.
Be sure to visit here and ask for Mary Pat, one of the owners, she is the sweetest! And because it’s only approximately a 10-minute drive away from The Fountain, you should definitely schedule this in your itinerary.
Scilly Cay
Just off the coast of Island Harbour, on Anguilla’s northeastern side. Hop on a free boat ride from Island Harbour only takes 2 minutes. Getting to Scilly Cay is half the fun. Simply head to Island Harbour, wave to the boat operator (Yes, literally just wave your arms!), and they’ll whisk you across the shimmering blue waters. No reservations, no schedule just classic, carefree island style.
Scilly Cay is famous for its mouthwatering seafood, grilled fresh to order over an open flame. The lobster, crayfish, and snapper are cooked to perfection, seasoned with Caribbean spices, and served alongside hearty rice and salad. The portions are huge; you’ll want to bring a big appetite!
A trip to Scilly Cay isn’t complete without their world-famous rum punch. Made with at least three types of rum, a splash of tropical fruit juices, and an extra kick of island magic, this drink is not for the faint of heart. Locals say one punch will relax you, two will make you dance, and three…well, good luck getting off the island! Sip slowly; this punch is dangerously strong!
Let’s go over to Sandy Ground, which is about 15 minutes’ drive away from The Fountain.
Dolce Vita – Sandy Ground
Sometimes, you just need Italian comfort food. Yes, even in the Caribbean. Dolce Vita delivers homemade pasta, dreamy seafood dishes, and a romantic waterfront setting that will make you want to stay forever.
Dolce Vita is a place where flavor, passion, and hospitality come together in the most delicious way possible. Whether you’re a pasta connoisseur, a wine lover, or simply someone who appreciates a truly outstanding meal, this is a must-visit spot during your time in Anguilla.
With an extensive wine list and dishes bursting with authentic Italian flavors, Dolce Vita brings a little slice of Italy to the Caribbean. Whether it’s a romantic date night or a family gathering, this spot never disappoints. The Cioppino and Nutella cheesecake will change your life, guaranteed.
And with just a 15-minute drive from The Fountain Anguilla, getting there is as easy as twirling a forkful of homemade fettuccine.
Roy’s Bayside Grill – Sandy Ground, Anguilla
This is a favorite spot for a hearty breakfast! Roy’s Bayside Grill is a beloved establishment known for its British-inspired menu and beachfront location. Guests can indulge in dishes like fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, and fresh seafood platters. The relaxed atmosphere and regular live music events make it a popular spot for both locals and tourists.
Straw Hat Restaurant – Meads Bay
About a 20-minute drive from The Fountain imagine sitting seaside, toes buried in the warm sand, while a salty ocean breeze flirts with your senses. Now add a plate of fresh, buttery snapper, a piña colada that tastes like pure sunshine, and the smooth sound of waves kissing the shore. That’s what you get at Straw Hat. The coconut cake alone is worth the trip.
The restaurant’s atmosphere balances refined dining with a relaxed, island-chic aesthetic. Locals and visitors alike rave about the service; warm, welcoming, and always ready with an excellent wine pairing recommendations. Whether you come for lunch or a candlelit dinner, every moment at Straw Hat is a sensory delight. The jerk-spiced mahi-mahi is a knockout, and their famous coconut cake is nothing short of legendary.
Blanchard’s Restaurant– Meads Bay
Like Straw Hat, Blanchard’s is about 20 minutes away from The Fountain. Blanchard’s is the kind of place you walk into and instantly feel at home, except this “home” happens to serve some of the most delicious Caribbean-inspired dishes you’ll ever taste. The outdoor patio is draped in twinkling lights, and there’s a laid-back yet elegant vibe that makes everything taste even better.
Blanchard’s menu is a love letter to the island’s vibrant flavors, crafted with a touch of sophistication. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and bold flavors makes every dish sing. Their coconut-crusted grouper is practically a work of art, and the lobster risotto? Heavenly. Whether you’re in the mood for seafood, steak, or a tropical-inspired vegetarian dish, they’ve got you covered.
Jacala – Meads Bay
An elegant yet effortless beachfront French-Caribbean bistro where the chefs greet you like an old friend and every dish feels like a love letter to flavor—that’s Jacala. It’s intimate, refined, and the kind of place you’ll dream about long after you leave.
Here, dining is an experience, with dishes plated so beautifully you almost hesitate to take the first bite. But once you do? Pure bliss. The menu is carefully curated, with French-inspired techniques complementing the fresh, locally sourced seafood. Their grilled crayfish is melt-in-your-mouth perfection, and the foie gras? Pure indulgence.
Sharky’s Restaurant – West End, Anguilla
Approximately 25 minute drive away from The Fountain, Sharky’s is a gem known for its warm hospitality and flavorful Caribbean dishes. The menu includes favorites like jerk chicken, coconut crusted fish, and a variety of vegetarian options. The intimate setting and personalized service make it a standout choice for those seeking an authentic dining experience.
Sunshine Shack – Rendezvous Bay
The distance from The Fountain Anguilla to Sunshine Shack is a 25-minute drive. If you want the true, toes-in-the-sand, sun-on-your-face beach shack experience, Sunshine Shack is your place. Owned and run by the ever-welcoming Garvey Lake, this iconic beach bar and grill is a slice of pure Caribbean joy. Expect reggae beats, friendly faces, and a barbecue that sends mouthwatering smoke signals across Rendezvous Bay.
The name of the game here is grilled perfection. Whether you go for the grilled ribs, jerk chicken, or fresh-caught fish, every bite is kissed by the smoky flavors of an open-flame barbecue. Their shrimp skewers are another knockout—plump, juicy, and lightly charred, served with Garvey’s signature hot sauce for that extra kick.
And let’s not forget the sides—fluffy coconut rice, sweet plantains, and crisp coleslaw round out the plates perfectly. Pair it all with an ice-cold Carib beer or a rum cocktail, and you’ve got the recipe for an afternoon you won’t want to end.
If you’re lucky, Garvey might even hand you a permanent marker and invite you to sign your name on the walls or furniture—because at the Sunshine Shack, everyone is family.
D’ Richard’s – Aurora
About 25 to 30 minute drive away from The Fountain, if you’re craving a refined yet unpretentious dining experience, D’ Richard’s is where you want to be. This hidden gem manages to blend casual comfort with gourmet finesse, making every meal feel like a special occasion even if you just wandered in straight from the beach.
The seafood pasta is legendary, generously loaded with succulent shrimp, scallops, and local lobster, all drenched in a rich, creamy sauce with a whisper of island spice. If you’re in the mood for something heartier, the slow-braised short ribs practically melt off the bone, served alongside buttery mashed potatoes and seasonal veggies.
And let’s talk drinks, because what’s a Caribbean evening without one? Their selection of wines and craft cocktails make it easy to linger a little longer under the warm, twinkling lights.
Final Thoughts: Your Anguilla Food Bucket List Awaits
If you’re a foodie, Anguilla is your dream destination and should be on your must-go list! Whether you’re indulging in fine dining or digging into fresh seafood at a beachside shack, every meal here feels like a special occasion. From Meads Bay’s oceanfront elegance to Shoal Bay’s laid-back charm and Sandy Ground’s lively nightlife scene, there’s a culinary adventure waiting at every turn.
And for the perfect home base to experience it all, Fountain Anguilla offers a luxurious yet comfortable stay in our Fountain Anguilla villa rentals just minutes away from these incredible dining spots. Book your stay today in one of our studio penthouses and turn your food-filled getaway into an unforgettable island escape in our rentals!
So, grab your fork, pack your appetite, and get ready to eat your way through paradise. Bon appétit, and happy feasting!